Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?


21 Short-Lived Modern Bands With Familiar Members That Need To Come Back

Featuring Arcadea, Fleshwrought, Serpentine Dominion, Them Crooked Vultures, and more!


Not every band is destined (or meant to) have a massive, lengthy career. Sometimes they exist for a few years, put out some great music that we'll listen to for years to come, and then fade away. Sometimes they come back, sometimes they don't. Check out these 21 relatively short-lived projects, whose members all have other notable bands that occupy their time, but still put out records that are still worth spinning today. Enjoy!


Arcadea is Mastodon drummer Brann Dailor, Zruda guitarist Core Atoms, and guitarist Raheem Amlani. Arcadea released their self-titled album in 2017 and, as of 2020 right before everything went to hell, was promising new music.

Asphalt Graves

Asphalt Graves is vocalist Jason Netherton (Misery Index, ex-Dying Fetus), guitarist Adam Faris (ex-War Torn), bassist Brent Purgason (Gwar, ex-Cannabis Corpse), and drummer Shannon Lucas (Serpentine Dominion, ex-All That Remains, ex-The Black Dahlia Murder). Asphalt Graves put out The New Primitive in 2016 and did a tape pressing in 2019, but other than that – nothing.

The Company Band

The Company Band – featuring Neil Fallon (Clutch), guitarists James A. Rota (Fireball Ministry) and Dave Bone, bassist Brad Davis (Fu Manchu), and drummer Jess Margera (CKY) – was a rock force to be reckoned with. The band dropped their self-titled in 2009, had an EP called Pros & Cons in 2012, and has since faded away.

Conquering Dystopia

Conquering Dystopia is guitarists Jeff Loomis (Arch Enemy, ex-Nevermore) and Keith Merrow (Nightmarer), bassist Alex Webster (Cannibal Corpse, Blotted Science), and drummer Alex Rudinger (ex-The Faceless, Good Tiger). The band released their self-titled album in 2014 and, as of 2019, was chipping away at a follow-up record.


Dunsmuir is vocalist Neil Fallon (Clutch, The Company Band), guitarist Dave Bone (The Company Band), bassist Brad Davis (Fu Manchu, The Company Band, ex-Fireball Ministry), and drummer Vinny Appice (Last In Line, ex-Black Sabbath, ex-Dio). The band released four 7" singles leading up to their 2016 debut album, but haven't said anything since 2017.


Expulsion recorded their debut (and only) EP Nightmare Future in 2017 as vocalist Matt Harvey (Exhumed, Gruesome, Pounder), guitarist Matt Olivo (Cryptic Slaughter, Repulsion), bassist Menno Verbaten (Behold! The Monolith, Cryptic Slaughter), and drummer Danny Walker (Phobia). Outside some posts from 2017 promoting the EP, Expulsion has remained dead quiet.


Fleshwrought is vocalist Jonny Davy (Job For A Cowboy, Serpent Of Gnosis) and multi-instrumentalist Navene Koperweis (Job For A Cowboy, Entheos). The band put out one record Dementia / Dyslexia in 2010 and, despite some teases and even announcing a bassist in 2014, never followed it up. Though now that Job For A Cowboy is back, a new Fleshwrought record feels unlikely.

Ghost Ship Octavius

Ghost Ship Octavius ended as drummer Van Williams (ex-Ashes Of Ares, ex-Nevermore) and guitarist Matt Wicklund (ex-God Forbid, ex-Himsa). Vocalist Adon Fanion left in 2020, and the band's original formation in 2013 contained (but never lasted with) bassist Sara Claudius (ex-The Obsessed) and guitarist Christopher Amott (Dark Tranquillity, ex-Arch Enemy). Ghost Ship Octavius had two albums between 2015 and 2018, and as of 2020 was auditioning bassists and vocalists.

God Seed

God Seed was formed after the Gorgoroth band name dispute in the late 2000s and only got around to releasing I Begin in 2012. The band was vocalist Gaahl (Gaahls Wyrd, ex-Gorgoroth), guitarists Sir (Trelldom, ex-Gaahls Wyrd) and Lust Kilman (Gaahls Wyrd), bassist King ov Hell (ex-I, ex-Gorgoroth), keyboardist Geir Bratland (Dimmu Borgir [live]), and drummer Kenneth Kapstad (Thorns, Trelldom).


Hey, speaking of a bunch of the God Seed guys! I released their sole album Between Two Worlds in 2006 and we're still talking about how insanely good it is. I was guitarist and vocalist Abbath (Abbath, ex-Immortal), guitarist Ice Dale (Enslaved) and bassist TC King (ex-Gorgoroth, ex-God Seed), drummer Armagedda (ex-Immortal), and lyricist Demonaz (Immortal). Given the Immortal split, an I reunion seems unlikely… but man, it would be awesome.

John Frum

John Frum is vocalist Derek Rydquist (The Zenith Passage, Bereft, ex-The Faceless), guitarist Matt Hollenberg (Cetus, Cleric), bassist Liam Wilson (Azusa, ex-The Dillinger Escape Plan), and drummer Eli Litwin (Deveykus, Intensus). The band released A Stirring In The Noos in 2017, and as of 2023 may soon get removed from this list.

Legend Of The Seagullmen

Legend Of The Seagullmen is drummer Danny Carey (Tool), guitarists Brent Hinds (Mastodon, Giraffe Tongue Orchestra) and Jimmy Hayward (director of Jonah Hex, etc.), bassist Pete Griffin (Zappa Plays Zappa, Dethklok), vocalist David Dreyer, and synth player Chris DiGiovanni. The band released their debut album in 2018, and as of 2021 unfortunately revealed that Hayward was battling cancer. So it's not clear what's happening in their camp right now (but we do wish Hayward the best).

Lesser Key

Lesser Key is vocalist Gilden Tunador, guitarist Brett Fanger, bassist Paul d'Amour (Ministry, ex-Tool), and drummer Justin Hanson (ex-3Teeth). Lesser Key released their debut self-titled EP in 2014 and then fell silent for a while. All we know at the moment is that as of late 2021, Lesser Key was promising their debut full-length album to be out a few years ago, but no additional information has yet surfaced.

Murder Construct

Murder Construct formed way back in the early 2000s, but only released an EP and an album between 2010 and 2012. The band's recording lineup was vocalist Travis Ryan (Cattle Decapitation), guitarist and vocalist Leon del Muerte (Impaled, ex-Exhumed, ex-Intronaut), guitarist Kevin Fetus (Watch Me Burn), bassist Caleb Schneider (Bad Acid Trip), and drummer Danny Walker (Phobia). Murder Construct released a remixed and remastered version of their only album Results in 2020, so that's a sign of life… right?

Necromancing The Stone

Necromancing The Stone is vocalist John Williams (ex-Brimstone Coven), guitarists James Malone (Arsis) and Justin Wood, bassist Bart Williams (ex-The Black Dahlia Murder), and drummer Jeramie Kling (The Absence, Inhuman Condition). The band released their gloriously heavy metal debut Jewel Of The Vile in 2016 and, aside from one post in 2021, has been dead quiet since 2018.

Storm Corrosion

Storm Corrosion is the project featuring Opeth's Mikael Åkerfeldt and Porcupine Tree's Steven Wilson. It's been 10 years since their one and only album, and Wilson said earlier in 2021 that he likes to think there will be another one someday. And hey – we got a Porcupine Tree reunion, so maybe there could really be another Storm Corrosion record? At least there was talk of a reissue.

Serpentine Dominion

Serpentine Dominion is vocalist George "Corpsegrinder" Fisher (Cannibal Corpse, Corpsegrinder), guitarist and bassist Adam Dutkiewicz (Killswitch Engage, Times Of Grace), and drummer Shannon Lucas (Asphalt Graves, ex-All That Remains, ex-The Black Dahlia Murder). The project was talked about for years until it finally dropped its debut self-titled album in 2016. All we know is that Fisher would be down to do a second record eventually.


Svavelvinter originally put out their 2014 EP Nidingsverk as vocalist Christian Älvestam (Miseration, ex-Scar Symmetry) and guitarist Christian Larsson. The project then dropped Mörkrets tid in 2018 as Älvestam alongside guests Johan Randén, Ronnie Björnström (Solution .45), Jocke Sund, and Thomas "Plec" Johansson (Torchbearer). The project has remained largely quiet in recent years, though Älvestam is usually a busy dude.

Them Crooked Vultures

Them Crooked Vultures is drummer Dave Grohl (Foo Fighters), bassist John Paul Jones (Led Zeppelin), and guitarist and vocalist Josh Homme (Queens Of The Stone Age). The band released their first and only album Them Crooked Vultures in 2009 and, despite the occasional comment here and there about the band getting back together every year or so, it hasn't happened yet.


T.R.A.M. is Animals As Leaders guitarists Tosin Abasi and Javier Reyes, drummer Eric Moore (ex-Infectious Grooves, ex-Suicidal Tendencies), and multi-instrumentalist Adrián Terrazas-González (ex-The Mars Volta) handling woodwinds and brass. T.R.A.M. has one record named Lingua Franca out in 2012 and that was it. The band's Facebook page is hardly updated anymore outside occasionally talking about some Terrazas-González guest spots.


Witherscape is drummer and vocalist Dan Swanö (Nightingale, ex-Edge Of Sanity, ex-Bloodbath) and guitarist and bassist Ragnar Widerberg (Shadowquest, ex-Witchcraft). Witherscape released two albums and an EP between 2013 and 2016 and then fell silent. The last update from the band was a comment to a fan in 2021 asking about if there were plans for new music, to which Witherscape responded "apart from the first album being [reissued on] vinyl later in the year, not."

Show Comments / Reactions

You May Also Like

Latest News

"So is there a chance? Yeah. There is. Is it a good chance? No."

Live Footage

Featuring a Them Crooked Vulture reunion, some Rush music, and of course Foo Fighters!