Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Latest News

MAYNARD JAMES KEENAN Says TOOL's Creative Process Is Run By Committee, "Even If It's F*cking Death By Committee"

It's not pretty, but it is beautiful.


Maynard James Keenan recently spoke with Rick Beato on his YouTube channel for an hour long conversation, touching on all of Keenan's projects: Puscifer, A Perfect Circle, and naturally, Tool. You can check the video out below.

Keenan shared some early memories of Puscifer being the musical attraction that accompanied performers on the sketch comedy scene in Los Angeles during the mid-nineties; a scene that included David Cross and Bob Odenkirk (which led to a connection with Mr. Show), Janeane Garofalo, Green Jellö, and Tenacious D.

Beato noted Keenan's ability to write lyrics and vocal melodies over riffs, something Keenan attributes to his understanding of rhythm, but he also spoke at length (no pun intended) about Tool's exhaustive creative process.

"[The guys in Tool], they just take longer to process information and get it together and then present me something that I can start building on," Keenan said. "I've made the mistake in the past of trying to build on something that wasn't ready yet, and then all the work I put into building on 'the thing', they changed the foundation. I'm trying to decorate the house and then you move where the doors are and move the windows or add a floor. I got to start over as an interior decorator. So I have to wait for them to do it. So there's time [for other musical projects]. I have time to do all these other things in between because I can and I should."

Keenan continued by adding, "One could argue a little bit of discipline and a little prodding [contributes to the extensive exercise of making Tool records.] A little cattle prod or a taser would help move those guys along a little faster, but that's their process. You just kind of respect it. You know it's frustrating. I'm sure they're frustrated with me because they hand it to me and I'm like 'It's done' — [and the band is] like, 'You didn't take any time with it?' Yes, I took 50 years—right?—for this reaction to these things. I've been preparing for decades to hear these things and be able to react honestly and I riff on them."

Ultimately, Keenan summarised that listening to each other and working by committee is the best recipe for success, at least for Tool , anyway. Asked if he has final say in the group, he firmly stated, "No… it has to be by committee. Even if it's fucking death by committee. It has to be by committee because you have to trust each other at the end of the day for it to be the full encompassing piece with several sets of eyes (and ears on it)."

Puscifer will be back on the road this October and November. Check the dates out below, alongside a recently released remix of "Bullet Train To Iowa" by A Perfect Circle guitarist Billy Howerdel.

10/13 San Francisco, CA The Warfield
10/15 Reno, NV Grand Theatre at the Grand Sierra Resort
10/16 Paso Robles, CA Vina Robles Amphitheatre
10/18 Escondido, CA California Center for Arts Escondido – Concert Hall
10/20 Tucson, AZ The Linda Ronstadt Music Hall (formerly Tucson Music Hall)
10/21 El Paso, TX Abraham Chavez Theatre
10/22 San Antonio, TX Tech Port Center & Arena
10/25 Houston, TX 713 Music Hall
10/26 Ft. Worth, TX Will Rogers Memorial Auditorium
10/28 New Orleans, LA Mahalia Jackson Theater
10/29 Baton Rouge, LA River Center Theatre
10/31 Nashville, TN Ryman Auditorium
11/1 Charlotte, NC Ovens Auditorium
11/3 Norfolk, VA Chrysler Hall
11/4 Washington, DC Warner Theatre
11/5 Atlantic City, NJ Sound Waves at Hard Rock Hotel & Casino
11/7 Montreal, QC MTelus
11/8 Toronto, ON Queen Elizabeth Theatre
11/10 Cincinnati, OH The Andrew J. Brady Music Center
11/11 Louisville, KY Louisville Palace
11/12 Indianapolis, IN Murat Theatre at Old National Centre
11/13 Madison, WI The Orpheum Theater
11/15 Grand Rapids, MI DeVos Performance Hall
11/17 St. Louis, MO The Factory
11/18 Kansas City, MO The Midland Theatre
11/19 Tulsa, OK Tulsa Theater
11/22 Prescott, AZ Yavapai College Performing Arts Center

Show Comments / Reactions

You May Also Like


From Meshuggah and Testament, to the Cavaleras and Manowar, it's been done quite a bit.

Mashups & Covers

"Danny, you got to you got to come in do [Dream Theater's] 'The Dance Of Eternity' now."

Latest News

Guitarist Stephen Carpenter continues to refuse to leave the US.